talking rum since 2022

A Tale of Two Worthy Park Rums: 2006 vs. 2007

\"\"

Recently, I finally sat down to do something I’d been meaning to do for months: a head-to-head comparison of two exceptional rums from the renowned Worthy Park estate in Jamaica. I’ve had both bottles open in my collection for some time—one picked up during a trip to Switzerland and the other acquired in the United States—but I had never taken the time to taste them side by side. With a quiet evening ahead, I decided it was the perfect opportunity to dive into this long-awaited comparison.

The two rums in question are the Worthy Park 2006 Single Estate Rum, aged for 12 years and bottled in 2018, and the Worthy Park 2007, aged for 10 years and bottled in 2017 by the independent bottler Velier. Both rums were aged in ex-bourbon barrels, though there’s no mention of charring levels or how many times the barrels were used before. Despite their similar origins, these two rums offered distinct experiences that made for a fascinating tasting session.

The Worthy Park 2006: Richness and Depth

I started with the Worthy Park 2006, and from the first sip, I was struck by its richness. The nose was inviting, with notes of ripe banana, toasted oak, and a hint of vanilla. On the palate, it was deep and layered, with flavors of caramel, tropical fruit, and a touch of baking spices. The finish was where this rum truly shone—long, satisfying, and packed with nuanced notes that lingered pleasantly. It felt like a rum that had truly come into its own, with a maturity and complexity that made each sip a delight.

The Worthy Park 2007: Lighter but Still Lovely

Next, I turned to the Worthy Park 2007, bottled by Velier. The nose was similarly inviting, though slightly brighter, with hints of citrus and coconut alongside the familiar Worthy Park touch. On the palate, it was lighter and more approachable, with flavors of pineapple, honey, and a touch of pepper. While enjoyable, it lacked the same depth and richness as the 2006, especially on the finish, which felt shorter and less complex.

Side by Side: A Study in Nuance

What made this tasting so fascinating was how similar yet different these two rums were. Both are unmistakably Worthy Park, but the difference of two years of aging and the difference in bottling years (2006 bottled in 2018 vs. 2007 bottled in 2017) created distinct expressions.

Over the course of 30 minutes, I went back and forth between the two, savoring their similarities and differences. Tasting rums at 56% and 59% ABV is no small feat—the alcohol punch is notable, and it’s not always easy to keep focus. I made sure to take my time, giving my palate plenty of rest between sips to fully appreciate each rum’s nuances.

Why the Difference?

This tasting left me with some intriguing questions: Was the extra two years of aging the primary reason for the 2006’s richer profile? Or did other factors, like the differences in harvest conditions, soil, or even the weather during those two years, play a role?

Aging is a complex process, influenced by countless variables. The 2006 and 2007 vintages could have experienced different climatic conditions, affecting the sugar content and flavor profile of the sugarcane. The soil composition might have shifted slightly, imparting subtle differences in the raw material. Even the fermentation process, though consistent in method, could have been influenced by ambient temperatures or microbial activity unique to each year.

Then there’s the aging itself. While both rums were aged in ex-bourbon barrels, the specific conditions of the warehouse—temperature fluctuations, humidity levels, and even the position of the barrels—could have contributed to their distinct profiles. The 2006, with its extra two years in the barrel, had more time to develop deeper, more integrated flavors, while the 2007 might have retained some of its brighter, fresher characteristics.

These are tough questions to answer definitively, but that’s part of what makes rum so fascinating. The interplay of time, terroir, and craftsmanship creates a tapestry of flavors that can vary dramatically even within the same distillery. This type of comparison reminds us just how complex and varied the rum-making process can be.

A Note on Worthy Park’s Ester Marks

Both of these rums carry the WPL mark, which stands for Worthy Park Light and falls within the ester range of 60-119 grams per hectoliter of pure alcohol (gr/hL AA). This places them in the medium ester category, offering a balance of fruity complexity and approachability.

Worthy Park is known for its range of ester marks, from the ultra-light WPUL to the heavier WPH (240-360 gr/hL AA) and even the WPE (up to 800 gr/hL AA). However, unlike some other Jamaican producers—such as Hampden, which can reach ester levels as high as 1600 gr/hL AA—Worthy Park tends to stay within a more restrained range. This makes their rums accessible while still retaining that quintessential Jamaican character. (For more on Worthy Park’s ester marks, I highly recommend the detailed breakdown on Cocktail Wonk—it’s an invaluable resource for rum enthusiasts.)

The Verdict: Personal Preference

In the end, the Worthy Park 2006 resonated with me more, thanks to its fuller flavor profile and that incredible finish. It felt like a rum that had reached its peak, with a richness and complexity that I couldn’t get enough of. That said, the Worthy Park 2007 was no slouch—it was still a well-crafted, enjoyable rum, and I can see it appealing to those who prefer a lighter, more approachable style.

Final Thoughts

This tasting was a reminder of how much small details—like an extra time of aging, differences in harvest conditions, or even the nuances of barrel aging—can shape a rum’s character. Both rums are excellent examples of Worthy Park’s craftsmanship, and it’s fascinating to see how the same distillery can produce such distinct expressions.

If you ever get the chance to try these rums side by side, I highly recommend it. It’s a journey worth taking, and it might just change the way you think about aging, terroir, and the art of rum-making.

Related articles

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Renato Molo
Royal Rum Society Rummelier®

Ecole hôtelière de Lausanne graduated

More articles
en_USEnglish

Nullam quis risus eget urna mollis ornare vel eu leo. Aenean lacinia bibendum nulla sedÂ